I joined MetaBrainz as Executive Director in August this year, 7 months after we lost Rob. This is the written summary of the talk I gave at our October summit in Barcelona: where we stand, what worries me, and what I plan to do in 2027.
A year of loss, and what held
Losing Rob this year touches everything in this report. What I want to recognize is how people responded:
- The team kept the lights on and the engines running.
- The community kept editing, even through the outages.
- The board focused on funding so we could keep going.
I wasn’t here yet for most of that, so the credit belongs to all of you.
Who I am
I started in August, and I’ve spent the months since learning how everything works. My first focus is infrastructure and the funding it requires. My second is raising money more broadly.
I’ve worked in open data, open standards and open source since 2004, mostly in open government. I care a great deal about privacy: I served on the board of EFF-Austin for 12 years and was a legislative liaison for the ACLU on technical issues. I also have a background in AI, which I know is a sore subject here but this means I can help. I have always fought for artists and creators, and I think you’ll find we’re in sync on the realities we face.
The money
At the time of the summit, income for 2026 stood at 300K, which put us 55K behind for this time of year. We normally bring in about 400K a year, and Nicolás (reosarevok) and I think we can still get there by year-end. But because of increased infrastructure costs we still have a shortfall for this year.
What has been done:
- The board has spent the year renewing supporter contracts.
- We are creating new kinds of contracts, because ListenBrainz is used very differently from MusicBrainz and our existing tiers don’t fit.
- I’ve been researching what comparable data sells for. The finding: our top tier is the industry standard price. Every tier below it is priced well under that, on purpose, to support small businesses and independent creators.
What is pushing costs up:
- Infrastructure. AI agent traffic means we need more capacity, and AI demand has raised hardware and networking prices.
- The summit. Flights cost about three times what they did, especially from the United States.
We are also building a CRM using Twenty, which is open source and self-hosted. It brings together what lives on our website and in our accounting, helps us track privacy requests, and lets us send fewer routine emails and more useful ones, such as yearly tax letters to donors.
The CRM matters for a reason specific to US nonprofits: we have to show the IRS that our support comes from a broad public, and individual donations count toward that. It is also what lets us write to our users to ask for support, which we are planning on doing for the first time soon.
The team
This is my view as the new person, not a measurement.
What I see is an extraordinarily dedicated group. It’s why I took this job: I wanted to work with data nerds. The volunteer engagement is remarkable, from the userscripts and apps people have built to the number of edits made through thick and thin. The team is self-motivated and self-organizing. Everyone wants to carry Rob’s legacy forward, and I am in awe of that.
I also see that people are tired, and I’m worried about burnout.
- Too many roles are unfilled. Teams of one or two people are not enough.
- Coordination could be better, which is why we worked on leads and roles at the summit.
- Our infrastructure needs serious attention. With it in better shape, we’d be more comfortable opening up to outside contributions.
Fixing this takes money, which is why so much of this post is about funding.
2027
I’m preparing two budgets for the board.
The conservative budget covers:
- Following up with supporters and past donors through the CRM.
- Two summits: one in person, and a Virtual Summit in spring with rooms and topics the whole community can join.
The aspirational budget adds:
- Edit-a-thons, code-a-thons and voting-a-thons attached to existing events, starting with an edit-a-thon in the fall. Picture a session the day before a metal festival or a classical music festival, where our editors go and find their people. Sponsorship for events comes out of companies’ marketing budgets, which are far larger than their donation budgets.
- A UX summit to review our interfaces together.
- Grants. I’ve found more than 30 to apply for, ranging from 250,000 to 5 million. Many EU heritage preservation grants fit us, because archiving is what we do. AI companies also fund nonprofits affected by AI traffic, and I intend to ask.
Two more things are on my list:
- Getting our name out to the right people. When I took this role, I kept hearing “Oh, that’s still around?” from people who used to edit. I don’t want mass publicity. I want to reach the people who are passionate about music and data.
- The website. It needs to explain who the team is, what a nonprofit open data project means, why human-verified data matters and why our editors are the reason it’s good. We also need better onboarding: tutorials, videos and a sandbox.
Thank you
Rob and I are very different people, though I think we shared the same fundamental views. One difference is that I do the money thing. Another is that I will resist getting involved in the code and we manage differently, which means we’ll need some new ways of communicating.
Thank you for everything, and for your patience while I fill some brightly colored shoes.
Silona Bonewald
Executive Director, MetaBrainz Foundation