The ODI publishes two reports on Sustainable Data Institutions

The Open Data Institute has just published two reports: Designing Sustainable Data Institutions and Designing Trustworthy Data Institutions which include insights provided by us regarding our MusicBrainz project.

When I was starting out MusicBrainz and was trying to work out how to make the project sustainable, I would’ve given just about anything to have access to these reports. I am proud that, nearly 20 years later, I was able to contribute to these reports so that others may benefit from our hard work.

I find the section Suggestions for those scoping, designing and running data institutions on page 40 of the PDF version of Designing Sustainable Data Institutions quite enlightening:

  1. Ensure your revenue model aligns with your organisational goals
  2. Understand how your revenue sources will change during your institution’s lifecycle
  3. Consider both financial and non-financial aspects of sustainability
  4. Identify and mitigate future risks
  5. Learn from others

Each of these points represent a whole collections of small lessons that I’ve learned by (often painful) experience of the past years. Also, I feel that these points are not strictly limited Data Institutions, but many also apply to making open source projects sustainable. If you’re in the business of running a data or open source organzation, I would strongly encourage you to read this paper!

Also very interesting is the second report about Designing Trustworthy Data Institutions:

For example, the representative from MusicBrainz said, “[A culture of honesty] builds trust, and this trust builds sustainability”

Compared to sustainability, the concepts of trust were much more clear to me from the beginning. However, that doesn’t make this report any less relevant — especially in current times, I welcome an emphasis on trust!

Thank you to the ODI for including MusicBrainz and doing all of the hard work on these reports!

 

MusicBrainz Server update, 2020-04-27

A large variety of issue types have been addressed in today’s release!

As a new feature, search indexes are now dumped and made available along with database dumps under the FTP directory search-indexes. They are mainly intended to be loaded on a MusicBrainz slave server to start a mirror with search.

Among improvements, a noticeable one is to lighten the area’s overview page that was heavily crowded with all sorts of relationships that have been scattered over more specific tabs.

As for bugfixes, the major one secures user/admin forms against CSRF attacks.

Thanks to atj for contributing code to support Traxsource URLs. Thanks to alex_s7, chaban, danbloo, Lotheric, murdos, Skeebadoo for reporting issues. Thanks to kellnerd, Jormangeud, mfmeulenbelt, salorock for updating the translations in German, Finnish, Dutch, Italian, respectively. And thanks to all others who tested the beta version!

The git tag is v-2020-04-27.

Bug

  • [MBS-10359] – Guess feat. artists from track titles do not give expected result
  • [MBS-10677] – Place type shown as null on WS event place rels
  • [MBS-10717] – Cookie attributes must be adjusted to work with with new behavior in browsers
  • [MBS-10719] – “remove PUID” edit doesn’t load
  • [MBS-10742] – “Show more” country miscount
  • [MBS-10756] – Inconsistent default sort order for recordings on Works page
  • [MBS-10778] – User/admin forms are prone to CSRF attacks

New Feature

  • [MBS-10546] – Dump MB Solr data along with MB DB full export

Improvement

  • [MBS-1921] – Display edit link under annotations
  • [MBS-9086] – Move most relationships away from area overview
  • [MBS-10666] – Collapse work artists when there are too many on merge pages
  • [MBS-10741] – Make “relationship [attribute] in use” pages consistent
  • [MBS-10755] – Add entity type restrictions for musik-sammler.de URLs
  • [MBS-10781] – Add support for Traxsource URLs

React Conversion Task

  • [MBS-10740] – Convert /relationship static pages to React
  • [MBS-10751] – Convert Remove PUID edits to React

MusicBrainz Server update, 2020-04-13

No Easter egg in today’s update but rather a dozen or so of small bugfixes and convenient improvements.

Thanks Rotab for the pair of bugfixes he submitted, to CatQuest, chaban, chirlu, FSpy, HibiscusKazeneko, JesseW, KRSCuan, MichelV, wcw1966 for issues they reported, to salorock for the Italian translation he updated, and to all others who tested the beta version!

The git tag is v-2020-04-13.

Bug

  • [MBS-7465] – Tag cloud isn’t updated
  • [MBS-9169] – Inconsistent locale identifiers
  • [MBS-9728] – Recently-added Unicode emojis can’t be used in titles
  • [MBS-9894] – Timeline shows future date
  • [MBS-10360] – Whitelist User-Agent header in CORS Preflight requests
  • [MBS-10640] – Incorrect donation status in “Donation Check” tab
  • [MBS-10688] – Attaching a CDTOC that already exists on the medium gives a cryptic error
  • [MBS-10718] – Duplicate series “part of” relationships which got grouped are harder to detect
  • [MBS-10730] – Recording is displayed twice in artist overview when credited multiple times

Task

  • [MBS-10735] – Remove (discontinued) CD Baby links from the sidebar

Improvement

  • [MBS-5641] – Show release language/script in reports ReleasesWithUnlikelyLanguageScript, NoLanguage and NoScript
  • [MBS-10679] – Link to the JSON WS from the Details tab
  • [MBS-10680] – Link to WS docs from the Details tab
  • [MBS-10724] – Make sorting options (area, date, artist) consistent
  • [MBS-10747] – Change wording/phrasing of status description for open edits
  • [MBS-10753] – Use artist sort names for artist collection ordering

A very important announcement

In these troubling times (New Roman) it has come to our Attention that our Esteemed program “Picard” (from now on known as “The Captain”) is written with Very Silly™ code. This will just not do!

The MetaBrainz Foundation is a very serious organisation! It will not stand for such Silly™ things as Moose, Tissues or Membranophones!

The program (from now on known as “Sir Patrick”) has in addition to pythonesque codings also several oblique references to: burlesque starships, electronic hair-colour, Monty (including “the full”), several references to technologically minded stick-figures, John Cage, and disused towels left by your mother!

For now the program’s (from now on known as St. Paddy) most recent new release (version 2.45!§🥷) vil quickly bee retracted (bzzt!) and replaced by Harder, Better, Faster, Stronger Picard (from now on known as (♫♪♬) (version 2.4√-1€DONTBLINK;)) – this to Prevent excesses such as: Rock climbing Monkies, Tobogganing Dates, Breakdancing Pastries and–

Right, that’s enough of that, we apologise for the previous part of this blog post, it is Very Silly™ and the MetaBrainz Foundation is a very serious organisation which does not abide with such silliness!

We will now return to our regular scheduled blog post! –

Now look here!

What? Stop this at once!

That’s it, I quit!

MusicBrainz Server update, 2020-03-31

This time we have a couple bugfixes, a couple of small improvements, and continued changes to simplify the React table code.

Thanks to chaban, kellnerd, Kid Devine, and all others who submitted patches, reported issues, tested beta version, or contributed to translations!

The git tag is v-2020-03-31.

Bug

  • [MBS-10704] – Relationships header shown for works with no rels to be displayed
  • [MBS-10707] – Open Add DiscID edit already adds discID, cancelling does not remove it
  • [MBS-10712] – ISE when trying to load “merge release” edit

Improvement

  • [MBS-10669] – Restrict “Metal Archives” album links to release
  • [MBS-10699] – Remove “medley” from Guess Case when at the end of a title

Task

  • [MBS-10365] – Refactor display of entity list/table
  • [MBS-0401] – Replace handshaking protocol with bit mask